
What a buyer can settle for besides money: Deutsche Bahn and Talgo
A buyer is waiting for 79 long-distance trains.
The date they were due to run has moved twice, and the locomotives that pull them have moved as well.
If you buy for a company, you know this chair.
The contract is signed, the date has moved, and the next meeting is about what happens now.
The buyer was Deutsche Bahn.
The supplier was the Spanish train maker Talgo.
What happened
In February 2019 Deutsche Bahn signed a framework contract with Talgo for up to 100 trains, and ordered 23 of them straight away.
In May 2023 it ordered 56 more, so 79 were firmly ordered.
The trains were meant to run from December 2023.
Approval and production delays moved that to December 2024, and then into 2025.
The locomotives slipped to 2026, and Deutsche Bahn planned an interim solution with other locomotives.
In May 2025 Deutsche Bahn said it intended to cut the order from 79 trains to 60.
Talgo's chief executive was quoted in the rail press saying that "everything is on the table".
Deutsche Bahn did not comment on the talks.
The trains received their German approval in August 2025.
On 16 December 2025 Talgo told the Spanish securities regulator that a settlement had been signed.
What was agreed
Four things are public.
60 trains instead of 79.
The framework stays open up to 100.
A new delivery calendar.
And a new long-term maintenance and overhaul contract for Talgo.
The first read: the answer came in other currencies
A late supplier and a buyer with a signed contract.
The obvious conversation is about money.
At SBB, the other late train order I wrote about, the money sat in a penalty clause, and the clause ran out before the problem did.
What the public record shows here is a different set of things.
Fewer trains, a calendar the supplier now has to meet, and the right to come back to 100 still open.
Whether money moved as well is not in anything I could read, and the buyer has not said.
One of the three is worth weighing rather than counting.
The right to come back to 100 costs the supplier little to give, and it lets the market read the framework as intact.
What it is worth to the buyer depends on whether the buyer ever means to use it.
And one more thing sits in the dates.
In May, Deutsche Bahn named 60 in public.
In December, the settlement says 60.
And the supplier keeps something too.
Talgo gets years of maintenance work on the trains it builds.
The relationship continues long after the last train is delivered.
And it binds the buyer just as long, to the supplier whose dates have slipped.
Over a train's life, the maintenance can be worth more than the train.
From the buyer's chair, I would want to know what that contract bought in the room.
The second read: the cost was on the record before the deal
At the end of September 2025, three months before the settlement, Talgo published its results for the first half of the year.
As El Español and the rail site Trenvista reported them, Talgo made a loss and attributed part of it to a negative adjustment of about 40 million euros, linked to the expected smaller order from Germany.
The settlement was still being negotiated.
Talgo is listed, and a listed company has to report what it expects to lose.
So the report was a duty.
From the buyer's side of the table, it was still information.
Before the talks had ended, the supplier had already written a smaller order into its own accounts.
A supplier that has already booked the smaller order is no longer negotiating whether.
Only on what terms.
What is on the record is one half of what we bring into the room. The other half is what we build ourselves, the way Ryanair built its alternative before the conversation with Boeing started.
And one half is never on paper at all, on either side of the table.
I learned that at my own table.
After a meeting in person, the behaviour of my counterpart changed. The meetings that followed, phone and online, were different, and nothing in any file said why.
Weeks later we sat in person again, and I opened with a question I would normally never open with: what happened, what did I do?
The answer showed me we had read the same situation from two different perspectives. I had been in mine. She had been in hers. After I asked, we had both.
It would be easy if people simply said what they think and how they feel. They do not. So we notice, and we test what we assume.
What the record does not show
Deutsche Bahn's procurement team is not on the record.
We see the buyer through what was agreed, and the supplier through what it had to publish.
So I do not know what Deutsche Bahn asked for first, or what it gave up on the way.
Nor how the result was counted inside Deutsche Bahn afterwards, as a saving or as something else.
Something to use
Before the next conversation with a supplier whose date has moved, three things.
The check.
If the supplier is listed, its last report can carry a provision or an adjustment that touches our contract.
If it does, we can see before we sit down what the supplier has already booked against it.
The list.
Everything besides money that could move between us: units, dates, options kept open, years of service.
And next to each one, what it costs us and what it may be worth to them.
Something cheap for us can be worth a lot to them, so we trade it rather than give it.
The questions.
The ones I would ask myself before that meeting, from the buyer's chair.
Did we have enough information in advance?
Did we ask the right questions?
Did we have alternatives?
Have the same people been at the table through the years of delay?
A promise not kept has a price beyond the invoice.
Both sides carry it into the next conversation, whoever ends up paying.
And the question across the table is itself a signal, so it depends on where we stand.
Before the first delay, I can ask about their world: "What would make this calendar one you can keep?"
Asking it after the second delay says I no longer count on the calendar alone. With a counterpart who has already let a date slip, that is what I want it to say, and my question changes: "What will you do if you do not keep it?"
And the answer does not stay in the conversation. It goes into the agreement, as checks and as penalties.
Be well,
Tina
The Human Signal, my newsletter on LinkedIn, comes back in January with a new season, eight editions, each on one negotiation topic.